Located in the heart of Ohio’s Amish Country, the Ohio Star Theater in Sugarcreek offers a uniquely wholesome and engaging entertainment experience. First opened in 2012 and located within the Dutch Valley campus, this cozy yet elegant venue has quickly become a favorite destination for family-friendly musicals, gospel concerts, clean comedy, and inspirational performances.
What sets the Ohio Star Theater apart is its commitment to uplifting programming. It’s a place where tradition meets talent, where visitors from across the Midwest gather to enjoy world-class productions in a tranquil and picturesque setting. Whether you're attending a faith-based musical, a nationally touring comedian, or a Southern Gospel concert, each show at the Ohio Star Theater is crafted to inspire and delight.
With its growing reputation and welcoming ambiance, the venue draws visitors year-round. If you’re looking for an unforgettable performance that aligns with both high entertainment standards and family values, Ohio Star Theater is your destination.
Buying tickets with Box Office Ticket Sales is simple, fast, and secure.
Browse Events – Explore upcoming games, concerts and more.
Pick Your Seats – Use our interactive map to view real-time availability and compare prices
Secure Checkout – Pay easily with card, PayPal, Apple Pay, or Affirm
Digital Delivery – Tickets will be sent via email or mobile entry prior to your event date
Need Help? Here are several options in reaching our customer support team:
All tickets are 100% verified and guaranteed for on-time delivery
Safe & Secure Ticketing – With over 1 million happy customers since 2012, we take your security seriously:
Personalized Help Service:
The Ohio Star Theater features a spacious and intimate layout with just under 500 seats, making every seat feel close to the action. Designed with audience comfort in mind, the venue’s seating is tiered and cushioned, ensuring excellent views and acoustics throughout.
With Box Office Ticket Sales’ interactive seat map, you can easily select the section that best suits your preferences and budget. Don’t wait—some performances sell out weeks in advance!
Venue Address:
Ohio Star Theater
1387 Old Route 39
Sugarcreek, OH 44681
Parking
Free parking is available onsite at the Dutch Valley campus. The lot offers plenty of spaces for cars, buses, and RVs, and it’s just a short walk to the theater entrance. Parking attendants are typically present on event nights to assist with traffic flow.
Public Transit
Due to the rural location of Sugarcreek, public transit options are limited. Visitors from out of town often choose to drive or stay overnight at nearby lodging options.
Rideshare & Drop-off
While rideshare services such as Uber and Lyft are less common in the area, private shuttle arrangements and taxis may be available through local providers. There is a designated drop-off area at the theater entrance for guest convenience.
Guests are encouraged to arrive at least 30–45 minutes before showtime to allow time for parking, ticket scanning, and finding their seats. The lobby opens an hour before curtain, offering an opportunity to explore merchandise, concessions, or simply relax in the peaceful atmosphere of the Dutch Valley campus.
Navigating the Ohio Star Theater is simple and stress-free. The single-level design, clear signage, and helpful staff ensure that guests can locate restrooms, concessions, and their seats with ease.
Staff members are available to assist with seating, accessibility, and directions throughout your visit.
Bag Policy
Small purses and bags are permitted but may be subject to inspection. Large bags, coolers, and backpacks are not allowed inside the venue.
Prohibited Items
To maintain a safe and family-friendly environment, weapons, outside food and beverages, alcohol, and noise-making devices are prohibited. Photography and video recording policies may vary by event.
Re-Entry
Guests may exit and re-enter with appropriate hand-stamping and ticket validation, though it’s best to confirm with the usher team during your visit.
Service Animals
Service animals trained to assist guests with disabilities are welcome. Emotional support animals and pets are not permitted.
Traffic is minimal in Sugarcreek, but planning ahead ensures a smooth experience. For groups or tour buses, it’s helpful to coordinate arrival and meeting locations beforehand.
The Dutch Valley Restaurant and Dutch Valley Inn offer convenient pre- and post-show dining and accommodations within walking distance of the theater. Many guests enjoy combining their Ohio Star Theater experience with shopping at the Dutch Valley Gifts store or exploring the local Amish markets.
The Ohio Star Theater is fully accessible for guests with mobility challenges. Features include:
At Box Office Ticket Sales, we’re happy to help you select accessible seats—just reach out to our customer service team.
Dining is one of the highlights of any visit to the Dutch Valley campus. Top nearby options include:
Onsite concessions provide a selection of snacks, coffee, and soft drinks.
Whether you’re staying for the day or the weekend, Sugarcreek offers charming attractions:
Don’t wait—tickets for Ohio Star Theater events often sell fast. Whether you're planning a special night out or treating yourself to a musical escape, Box Office Ticket Sales is your go-to source for verified, hassle-free ticketing.
Browse tickets now and experience the best of live entertainment in Sugarcreek, Ohio.
Call us at 1-800-515-2171 to purchase tickets by phone.
Good
Very easy to use.
Quick & easy
Good
Excellent
Quick and easy. Thank you.
Great
good
buying tickets was so easy
Love the site
Great experience
great
Great
Thank you
Ok
Easy to purchase tickets thanks
Quick and essy!
You don't explain seating well but, ty
Easy web site
Great overall experience
Fast and easy
Very easy experience
quick and easy
Was real easy to use
It was easy to work thru, everything was at a finger tip
Very easy to purchase tickets
Very convenient
Quick and easy. Wish they had thev360 view on here
Easy checkout and fast!
Happy to get tickets from the box office
Ok
No comment
Thank you
Everything so far was great. I will be in touch if I have any questions.
Quick and user friendly, thank you
Very good
So glad I found the box office website. The transaction was easy
AS LOMG S I CAN PRINT MY TICKETS EVERTHING IS GREAT
Fast Quick Easy
So far so good!
It was very easy and simple getting my tickets I really recommend it.
Quick and easy to access the purchasing tickets
My shopping experience was excellent
It’s simple and easy to shop with Affirm.
Everything is good
Satisfied
Looking forward to it
This was quick and easy.
Vas easy and relaxing
Fast and easy
Good
Very easy to use.
Quick & easy
Good
Excellent
Quick and easy. Thank you.
Great
good
buying tickets was so easy
Love the site
Box Office Ticket Sales is a leading resale marketplace for concerts, sports, and theater event tickets. Established in 2012, over 1 million customers have used Box Office Ticket Sales to purchase tickets and experience the thrill of live events. Every step of the ticket buying process is safeguarded to ensure the highest levels of security where customers have access to search over 125,000 unique events. Prices may be above or below face value.